Three distinct sessions using Enemy Pie: identify assumptions, track evidence of change, then plan a respectful friendship action. These The full editorial edition is open: use all three sessions, teacher guidance, differentiation, and low-ink printables with your class.
Session 1: Facts, Assumptions, and First Impressions
Use the pacing, prompts, differentiation, teacher guidance, and printable below as a complete lesson. Choose the version that fits your available class time.
Prepare
5 min
Watch
10 min
Discuss
8 min
Student task
12 min
Choose your pacing
20 minutes
1 video pause · 2 discussion questions · oral task
30 minutes
2 video pauses · 3 discussion questions · guided task
45 minutes
2 video pauses · 3 discussion questions · full task
Learning goals
Students distinguish a story fact from a character’s assumption.
Students explain an initial opinion using one story detail.
Teacher preparation
Materials
Session 1 low-ink evidence sheet, Pencil
Before reading
Open the conversation
“What is the difference between what we know and what we think might be true?”
During reading
Evidence-based pauses
After the narrator names Jeremy as his enemy
Which details are facts? Which part is the narrator’s conclusion?
When Dad begins making the pie
What does the narrator assume the pie will do? What evidence does he have?
After reading
Three levels of discussion
1
comprehension
Why does the narrator call Jeremy an enemy at the beginning?
2
inference
What does the narrator expect will happen when Jeremy eats the pie?
3
connection
What question could you ask before deciding what someone is like?
Support
Use the frames “The story says ___” and “He thinks ___.”
Allow drawing plus an oral explanation.
Core task
Record one fact from the story.
Record one assumption the narrator makes.
Circle the evidence that supports your answer and share it with a partner.
Extend
Write a question the narrator could ask Jeremy to test his assumption.
Teacher reference
What to listen for
A fact is directly shown or stated; an assumption is a belief formed without enough evidence.
Avoid asking students to identify real classmates as enemies.
Substitute-ready summary
Help students separate facts shown in the story from the narrator’s assumptions, then support one idea with story evidence.
Watch for
Students may treat any strong opinion as a fact; return to whether the video directly shows or states the information.
Do not ask students to name real classmates they consider enemies. Keep examples fictional or general.
Ready to teach
Editorial review, source, printable, and license checks are complete.
Session 2: Track How a Character’s Thinking Changes
Use the pacing, prompts, differentiation, teacher guidance, and printable below as a complete lesson. Choose the version that fits your available class time.
Prepare
5 min
Watch
8 min
Discuss
10 min
Student task
12 min
Choose your pacing
20 minutes
1 video pause · 2 discussion questions · oral task
30 minutes
2 video pauses · 3 discussion questions · guided task
45 minutes
2 video pauses · 3 discussion questions · full task
Learning goals
Students sequence three events that change a character’s thinking.
Students support a turning point with story evidence.
Session 3: Turn Story Evidence into a Friendship Action
Use the pacing, prompts, differentiation, teacher guidance, and printable below as a complete lesson. Choose the version that fits your available class time.
Prepare
5 min
Watch
6 min
Discuss
9 min
Student task
15 min
Choose your pacing
20 minutes
1 video pause · 2 discussion questions · oral task
30 minutes
2 video pauses · 3 discussion questions · guided task
45 minutes
2 video pauses · 3 discussion questions · full task
Learning goals
Students explain how one action affected the relationship.
Students plan one safe, low-pressure friendship action.
Teacher preparation
Materials
Session 3 low-ink action planner, Pencil
Before reading
Open the conversation
“Which small actions can help two people learn more about each other without forcing friendship?”
During reading
Evidence-based pauses
When Dad explains the rule for enemy pie
How does spending a day together create a chance for new evidence?
At the final friendship reveal
Which actions—not labels—changed the relationship?
After reading
Three levels of discussion
1
comprehension
What rule does Dad give before serving the pie?
2
inference
Why might Dad choose this plan instead of correcting the narrator directly?
3
connection
What is one respectful action for welcoming someone new?
Support
Offer choices: invite, ask a question, share space, or offer help.
Use the frame “I could ___. The other person can choose ___.”
Core task
Choose a realistic classroom or playground situation.
Plan one friendly action that respects the other person’s choice.
Write what you might say and how you will know the action was respectful.
Extend
Add a possible response if the other person says no or wants space.
Teacher reference
What to listen for
Emphasize that kindness does not require instant friendship.
Reward respectful boundaries, not only positive acceptance.
Substitute-ready summary
Students connect one relationship-changing action from the story to a respectful, optional friendship action at school.
Watch for
Kindness does not guarantee friendship; a respectful plan must leave room for the other person to decline.
Avoid requiring reconciliation, physical contact, or disclosure of a real peer conflict.
Ready to teach
Editorial review, source, printable, and license checks are complete.